Boley Insurance Named a GEICO Top 50 MVP for 2025

There is some big news buzzing around the streets of Lakeland, and we simply couldn’t wait to share it with our neighbors. If you’ve spent any time around our office lately, you’ve probably heard our favorite catchphrase: Holy Moly Boley! Well, today we have a very special reason to shout it from the rooftops.

We are incredibly honored to announce that Boley Insurance, your local GEICO Exclusive Agency right here in Lakeland, has been officially recognized by GEICO as a Top 50 Most Valuable Partner (MVP) for 2025.

Now, we know what you might be thinking: “That sounds great, but what does it actually mean for me?” In the world of insurance, this is a massive milestone. Out of more than 300 GEICO Exclusive Agencies across the entire United States, our local team was selected as one of the top 50. This award isn’t just about numbers; it’s about excellence, collaboration, and a relentless commitment to providing the best service possible to our community.

A Tradition of Excellence in Lakeland

When James Boley started this agency, he had one goal in mind: to provide Florida residents with the kind of personalized, high-quality insurance solutions they deserve. Being named a Top 50 MVP is a testament to the hard work our team puts in every single day.  

Our agency isn’t just a building; it’s a powerhouse of local expertise. Our team consists of seven licensed insurance agents who bring a staggering 120 years of combined experience to the table. Whether you are looking for auto insurance in Florida or need to navigate the complexities of homeowners insurance in Florida, you aren’t just talking to someone in a remote call center. You are talking to experts who live, work, and play in the same neighborhoods as you.

Why the “MVP” Designation Matters to You

GEICO’s MVP partners are chosen because they exemplify excellence through strong collaboration and outstanding performance. For you, our valued client, this means a few things:

1. Superior Product Knowledge: We don’t just sell policies; we understand them inside and out. With over a century of combined experience, we know how to find the coverage that fits your life perfectly.
2. Proven Reliability: Being in the top tier of agencies nationwide means we have a track record of being there when our clients need us most.
3. Local Advocacy: We represent the “best of the best” in the GEICO Exclusive Agency program, giving us the tools and the standing to advocate for our Lakeland residents.

As reported by the Lakeland Chamber of Commerce, this recognition is no small feat. It places us in the top 15% of GEICO exclusive agencies in the nation. We are proud to bring that level of national excellence home to Polk County.

A Year of Major Wins: From SBA Month to the Top 50

This MVP recognition is really the cherry on top of an incredible year for us. Earlier in 2025, we were also named the Lakeland Chamber’s January 2025 Small Business of the Month.

We believe that our success comes from our “Local-First” approach. As a veteran-owned business, James and Michelle have instilled a culture of discipline, respect, and old-school customer service. We’ve all dealt with the frustration of automated phone trees and outsourced call centers.

At Boley Insurance, we do things differently.

• No Automated Systems: When you call our office us, you speak to a real person.
• Accessible Hours: We offer extended office hours and Saturday availability because we know life doesn’t stop at 5:00 PM on Friday.
• Community Focused: From our support of the Lakeland Chamber to our daily interactions with neighbors, we are invested in the success of our city.

More Than Just GEICO

While we are incredibly proud to be a GEICO Exclusive Agency, did you know that we also offer policies from several other insurance companies? This flexibility allows us to truly tailor our solutions. If GEICO isn’t the perfect fit for a specific, niche need, we have the partnerships to find a policy that is. We are your one-stop shop for:

• Boat and Watercraft Insurance
• Renters Insurance
• RV and Camping Insurance
• Umbrella Policies
• Motorcycle Insurance
• Jewelry Insurance

Security for Your Family’s Future

At the end of the day, insurance is about peace of mind. It’s about knowing that when you tuck your kids in at night or park your car in the driveway, you have a safety net in place. Our mission at Boley Insurance is to simplify the insurance-buying process so you can focus on what matters most: living your life.

We aren’t just selling you a piece of paper; we’re building a relationship. That’s why we’ve stayed in Lakeland, why we’ve grown our team to include seven dedicated agents, and why we continue to strive for awards like the GEICO Top 50 MVP. We want to be the agency you trust for a lifetime.

Ready to Experience the MVP Treatment?

You don’t have to settle for “average” insurance service. Come see why our rates and service are so great you’ll shout, “Holy Moly Boley!”

Whether you are a new resident moving to Polk County or a long-time neighbor looking to save some money on your monthly premiums, we are here for you. We’ll help you navigate the world of Florida insurance with transparency, honesty, and a friendly smile.

Get Your Quote Today!

Call Us: Reach out to a live, local agent at 863-258-9088.

Visit Us: Stop by our office in Lakeland to chat in person.

Online: Fill out our Rate Quote Request Form to get started from the comfort of your couch.

Thank you, Lakeland, for being part of our journey. We couldn’t have reached the Top 50 without you!

Frequently Asked Questions